Pages

Tuesday, November 28, 2023

 Devil with a blue dress on? Using primary sources and corroboration to determine the facts surrounding the capture of Jefferson Davis.

Kenneth V. Anthony, Mississippi State University

Emma L. O'Connor, DeKalb County Schools

National Council for the Social Studies Conference

Nashville, TN

December 2023

Slides: https://padlet.com/knnthanthony/jefferson-davis-powerpoint-cvv8hh5gc5y22uoy

1.      Disinformation is a threat to our democracy and our students individually.

2.      One model and one process (Wineburg, 1991)

a.         Model: Historical Thinking Heuristics

i.     Sourcing

ii.     Contextualization

iii.     Corroboration

iv.     Close reading

b.        Process: Primary Source Analysis (ORQ) https://www.loc.gov/programs/teachers/getting-started-with-primary-sources/guides/

i.     Observe

ii.     Reflect

iii.     Question

3.      Primary source accounts of the capture of Jefferson Davis

a.         A “so called president” in petticoats https://www.loc.gov/item/2008661797/

b.        Jeff’s Soliloquy to be or not to be (hanged) that’s the question https://www.loc.gov/item/2019635451/

c.         Jeff’s last skedaddle off to the last ditch https://www.loc.gov/item/2008661833/

d.        How is Davis portrayed and why?”

 

3. Evaluating the messages

a. Sourcing

a. Who is the artist?

b. What is the artist’s purpose?

c. Who is the audience?

b. Contextualizing

a. What is this event?

b. What else is going on at this time?

c. What has recently happened?

c. Corroboration

d. What do these media accounts have in common?

4.      Quick context

a.         Time

i.     APRIL 2, 1865- Jefferson Davis and most of Confederate government evacuate Richmond, VA.

ii.     APRIL 9, 1865- Robert. E. Lee surrenders to U.S. Grant at Appomattox

iii.      APRIL 15, 1865- Lincoln Assassinated

iv.      MAY 5, 1865- Davis dissolves the Confederate government at Washington, GA

v.     MAY 10, 1865- Davis captured near Irwinville, GA

b.        Place

i.     Jefferson Davis Capture Site 31.6633, 83.3860 338 Jeff Davis Park Road

Fitzgerald, Georgia, 31750 United States

ii.     South Georgia

c.         On location

i.     How is the event characterized on the historical markers?

 

 5.      Corroboration

a.         How is the event described or characterized in other documents (primary and secondary)?

b.        Primary sources

i.     The last act of the drama of secession https://www.loc.gov/item/2008661829/

ii.     Jefferson Davis account from A Short History of the Confederate States, 1889

iii.     Accounts from soldiers in the First Wisconsin who were present at his capture http://www.loc.gov/resource/lhbum.7689c_0562_0578

iv.     General U.S. Grant

c.         Secondary sources

i.     On this day in history

https://www.history.com/this-day-in-history/jefferson-davis-captured

ii.     America’s Library (Library of Congress) http://www.americaslibrary.gov/jb/civil/jb_civil_jeffdav_1.html

iii.     American Heritage

Fall 2010  Volume 60 Issue 3

https://www.americanheritage.com/was-jefferson-davis-captured-dress#4

d.        Artifacts

I.                                                     National Archives had possession of Davis’s spurs, raincoat, and shawl until they were                             returned to the heirs who gave them to the Jefferson Davis Presidential Library in                                     Biloxi, MS

https://text-message.blogs.archives.gov/2015/09/29/the-national-archives-and-jefferson-davis-cloak-shawl-and-spurs/ 





6.      Evaluating the messages

a.      Sourcing

a. Who is the artist?

b. What is the artist’s purpose?

c. Who is the audience?

b. Contextualizing

a. What is this event?

b. What else is going on at this time?

c. What has recently happened?

c. Corroboration

d. What do these media accounts have in common?

 

7.      Getting the facts straight

a.         What are the facts we know about the capture of Jefferson Davis?

b.        What have we learned about how history is written or presented?

c.         What have we learned about how media accounts can be misleading, wrong, or distorted?

d.        Who pushed the misleading narrative about Davis’s capture?

e.         How can we use multiple sources (including primary and secondary sources) to corroborate the details about historical events and media accounts?

8.  Conclusion

a.         The media accounts of Davis’s capture demonstrate how the press, the government, and others can create and push a false narrative.

b.        Schools can help combat the

spread of disinformation.

c.         Students can use historical thinking skills to evaluate media narratives and avoid accepting disinformation as fact.

Foreign influence operations—which include covert actions by foreign governments to influence U.S. political sentiment or public discourse—are not a new problem. But the interconnectedness of the modern world, combined with the anonymity of the Internet, have changed the nature of the threat and how the FBI and its partners must address it. The goal of these foreign influence operations directed against the United States is to spread disinformation, sow discord, and, ultimately, undermine confidence in our democratic institutions and values.

https://www.fbi.gov/investigate/counterintelligence/foreign-influence


Monday, October 30, 2023

Growing Popular Culture: Muddy Waters and Langston Hughes Spreading the Blues

 Growing Popular Culture: Muddy Waters and Langston Hughes Spreading the Blues

Mississippi Department of Archives and History: 38th Social Studies Teachers Workshop

November 3, 2023

Kenneth V. Anthony and Valencia Epps

Mississippi State University

_____________________________________________________________________________________

 

A Gloomy Day in Newport

 

“It’s a gloomy day at Newport, It’s a gloomy, gloomy day.

It’s a gloomy day at Newport, My music’s going away.

What’s gonna happen to my music? What’s gonna happen to my song?”[i]

 

Otis Spann, pianist for the Muddy Waters Band, sang the lines of the song that poet and Newport Jazz Festival board member,[ii] Langston Hughes had written on the back of a Western Union telegram sheet.[iii] It was the final song of the blues music session scheduled for Sunday afternoon, July 3, 1960. The Jazz Festival was cut short after thousands of people rioted because they could not get into the Jazz Festival at Freebody Park, Newport on the previous day.[iv] The National Guard and state police were called in to quell the riot.[v] Muddy Waters was the final act of a blues session organized by Hughes to bring blues to a white audience. The blues session is considered the first time that blues was played for a large white audience. According to David Whiteis, Muddy Waters’s performance at Newport “ranks as one of the most culturally and musically significant moments of the 20th century.”[vi]

 

The Sunday blues performances included the Sammy Price Trio, Betty Jeanette, Al and Leone, John Lee Hooker, Butch Cage and Willie Thomas, Myra Johnson, and the Muddy Waters Band. Interspersed into the musical performance was an educational program that included Langston Hughes's “Narrating the Blues.” [vii]  During “Narrating the Blues” Hughes used a call-and-response format asking questions that another performer would answer. In this way, Hughes defined and described blues music to the audience. For example,

 

Langston Hughes: “Sammy, what are the blues?”

Answer: “The blues ain’t nothin’ but the dog-gone hear disease.”

Langston Hughes: “Lafayette, what’s the blues?”

Answer: “The blues ain’t nothing but a good man feelin’ bad.”

Langston Hughes: “Drummer man, what is the blues?”

Answer: “The blues ain’t nothin’ but wantin’ what you never had.”

Langston Hughes: “Betty Jeanette, tellin me, what are the blues?”

Answer: “Blues ain’t nothing but a good woman been done wrong.”

 

Through the call and response, Hughes demonstrated the sense of melancholy[viii] that “captured the suffering, anguish-and-hopes-of 300 years of slavery and tenant farming”[ix] that characterized Blues lyrics. If “Narrating the Blues” provided the audience with an introduction to the lyrical themes of the blues, the Sunday performance by the various blues musicians accomplished Hughes’s goal to promote “African-American culture through music” which was one of the reasons he became involved with the Newport Jazz Festival in 1956.[x]

 

The Muddy Waters Band was the final act of the Sunday Blues performance. Chess Records released the performance as a live album, Muddy Waters at Newport 1960 and included many of his hits from the 1950s including “Hoochie Coochie Man” (1954) and “I got my Mojo Working” (1957). The final song of the album is “Goodbye Newport Blues” which was written by Hughes and performed by the Muddy Waters Band.[xi] The Newport Jazz Festival not only introduced the Blues to white America but according to Gary Blailock, Muddy “Waters and his band unleash(ed) the full force of the blues on a transfixed audience.”[xii] Blailock’s assessment can be confirmed by listening to the full album or watching videos of the performance that are readily available on the internet. Hughes’s goal was to introduce the Blues and Waters to a larger audience and after Newport, his audience included white fans of Jazz music.[xiii] Further, his performance resulted in young whites in America “embracing the blues.”[xiv]

 

Taking the Delta Blues to Chicago and beyond

Muddy Waters[xv] was born at Jug’s Corner in Issaquena County Mississippi[xvi] in 1913.[xvii] The date of his birth has been reported as 1913, 1914, and 1915 by various sources. Alan Lomax recorded the year of his birth as 1913 in his 1941 interview with Waters.[xviii] In his interview with Lomax, Waters stated that he learned how to play guitar from legendary blues artist Son House and reported that his yearly income working as a sharecropper was less than $250.[xix] Lomax was traveling the deep south for the Library of Congress recording folk music in 1941 and 1942.[xx] Alan Lomax recorded Muddy Waters in August 1941 and July 1942. These recordings are available on The Complete Plantation Recordings Muddy Waters.[xxi] In one way the songs on the recordings are different from the songs he would later record in Chicago in that Waters is playing an acoustic guitar (as you will see below, Waters traded in his acoustic guitar for an electric guitar in Chicago). But the theme of disappointment and loss is evident. For example, after Waters played the first song “Country Blues,” Lomax asked him why he wrote the song. Muddy Waters replied that he “had been mistreated by a girl…” and “I just felt blue, and the song fell into my mind.”[xxii] After the second interview with Lomax, Waters determined that he could be a professional musician and followed other black Mississippians' example and migrated north to Chicago in 1943.[xxiii]

In Chicago, Muddy Waters modified his Delta Blues sound when he exchanged his acoustic guitar for an electric guitar. In some accounts he bought his first electric guitar in 1944[xxiv] others state that his uncle gave him an electric guitar.[xxv] According to Michael Hill, he made the switch because he “found he couldn’t command much attention unamplified in a crowded, noisy club.”[xxvi] It was this new electric sound that brought Muddy Waters commercial success leading to 16 hits on the R&B charts by 1960.[xxvii] And it was this sound that he brought to the largely white audience at Newport. As the “king of the Chicago blues,”[xxviii] he played primarily for black audiences in Chicago but was branching out to a larger audience. In 1958, Muddy Waters toured England playing with the Chris Barber Band. According to one writer, it was Waters’ tour of England that contributed to the intense British interest in Blues claiming that after the tour, “countless 10-15-year-olds were listening in the bedrooms to hard-to-come-by blues records they might have owned or borrowed.”[xxix]

The Blues had a Baby and they called it Rock and Roll

Muddy Waters’s electrified Delta Blues was a watershed in modern music in many ways. First, he influenced generations of guitar players. According to Michael Hill, Muddy Waters “electrified the blues” and his guitar “launched a thousand bands.” According to Rolling Stone some of the most accomplished rock guitarists acknowledge Waters’s influence including Jimi Hendrix, Eric Clapton, Jimmie Page, and Angus Young.[xxx] Many guitarists also copy his riffs for example compare Waters’s guitar riffs in “Mannish Boy” to George Thorogood in “Bad to the Bone.” Second, his blues groups included the elements that would become the modern rock band including two guitars, bass guitar, drums, and a piano.[xxxi] Third, many rock and roll musicians were influenced by him. In his song, “The Blues had a baby and they named it rock and roll,” Waters sang

“All you people, you know the blues got a soul

Well this is a story, a story never been told

Well you know the blues got pregnant

And they named the baby Rock and Roll.”[xxxii]

 

In the song, written in 1977, Muddy Waters acknowledges his and other blues musicians’ role in shaping rock and roll. Among the significant artists who were shaped by Waters are the Rolling Stones and Eric Clapton.[xxxiii] The Rolling Stones took their band name from a Muddy Waters song[xxxiv] and Eric Clapton in an interview with NPR acknowledged that he was most influenced by Muddy Waters. He stated that he would listen to Waters and try to “emulate the guitar great’s technique.” Clapton and Waters played together. In fact, Waters’s final live performance was with Clapton in Miami on June 30, 1982.[xxxv] It goes without saying that Clapton and Rolling Stones’ lead singer Mick Jagger were included in the young people listening to blues music in England after Waters’s 1958 tour.

A Long, Lasting, Living Legacy

               Muddy Waters’s accomplishments and influence as a musician have been recognized by many. He was inducted into the Blues Hall of Fame (1980) and the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame (1987). He was nominated by the Recording Academy of the United States for twelve Grammy Awards and won seven. The seventh was a Lifetime Achievement Award in 1992 which is given to performers “who, during their lifetimes, have made creative contributions of outstanding artistic significance to the field of recording.”[xxxvi] Interestingly, two of the groups that claim significant influence from Muddy Waters also have been recognized with the Lifetime Achievement Award by the Recording Academy-- the Rolling Stones in 1986 and Cream (Eric Clapton played guitar for Cream) in 2006.[xxxvii]

               Langston Hughes intended for the blues performance including Muddy Waters Band at Newport to broaden the appeal of blues music to a broader white audience. The performance at Newport did just that. More significantly, Waters’s Newport performance serves as a microcosm of his larger influence on popular culture and music. At Newport, Waters brought his Chicago blues sound that had previously been performed primarily in front of black audiences to a largely white audience. His larger influence brought the Delta blues from Mississippi to the world through the musical artists he helped shape in rock and roll, jazz, R&B, country and western, and hip hop.[xxxviii] On that gloomy day in Newport in July 1960, Langston Hughes and the Muddy Water Band asked what was going to happen to the blues. The answer is one they might not have anticipated. The blues would transform popular music and Muddy Waters’s music would be an influential part of that transformation.

Post-Script

Waters’s legacy continues. In October 2023, the Rolling Stones released, Hackney’s Diamonds, their first studio album since 2005. One of the songs is a cover of Muddy Waters’s song “Rolling Stones Blues.”[xxxix] The Rolling Stones once commented that they wanted to play the music that encouraged their listeners to become Muddy Waters fans. Joe Taysom described the Rolling Stones as a “gateway band” that encourages people to seek out the blues. With their cover of Muddy Waters’s “Rolling Stones Blues,” the band continues to honor Waters’s legacy and influence on their careers and encourage their listeners to become Muddy Waters and blues fans.



[i] Langston Hughes, “Newport Blues,” July 3, 1960, Langston Hughes Papers. James Weldon Johnson Collection in the Yale Collection of American Literature, Beinecke Rare Book and Manuscript Library. https://collections.library.yale.edu/catalog/17394775.

[ii] “Otis Spann Singing Langston Hughes’ newly composed Newport Blues,” July 3, 1960, Langston Hughes Papers. https://archives.yale.edu/repositories/11/archival_objects/347615.

[iii] Jack Tracy, Original liner notes from the album Muddy Waters at Newport 1960, (Waxtime Records, 2013).

[iv] Jack Tracy, Original liner notes from the album Muddy Waters at Newport 1960.

[v] Rick Massimo, I Got Song: A History of the Newport Folk Festival. Middletown, Connecticut, Wesleyan University Press, 2017, p. 27.

[vi] David Whiteis, “Blues Breakthrough at Newport,” n.d., The Coda Collection. https://codacollection.co/stories/blues-breakthrough-at-newport.

[vii] “Newport Jazz Festival: Program, 1960 July 3.” July 3, 1960. Langston Hughes Papers. https://archives.yale.edu/repositories/11/archival_objects/348561

[viii] Lucy Chauduri, “What is blues music?” Classical Music, BBC Music Magazine, November 28, 2022.  https://www.classical-music.com/features/articles/blues-music/

[ix] “What is the Blues?” The Blues. PBS. https://www.pbs.org/theblues/classroom/essaysblues.html.

[x] Khagendra Neupane, “The Intersection of Blues and Gospel in Langston Hughes’s Poetry”. Cognition, 5 (1):63-67, 2023. https://doi.org/10.3126/cognition.v5i1.55409.

[xi] Jack Tracy, Original liner notes from the album Muddy Waters at Newport 1960.

[xii] Gary Blailock, Liner notes, Muddy Waters at Newport, 1960, (Waxtime Records, September 2013).

[xiii] Michael Hill, “Muddy Waters Hall of Fame Essay,” Rock and Roll Hall of Fame, 1987 https://www.rockhall.com/inductees/muddy-waters.

[xiv] Karl Rohr, “Muddy Waters,” Mississippi Encyclopedia, Center for Study of Southern Culture, July 11, 2017, http://mississippiencyclopedia.org/entries/muddy-waters/.

[xv] Born McKinley Morganfield as cited by Karl Rohr, “Muddy Waters.”

[xvi] Karl Rohr, “Muddy Waters.”

[xvii] According to the Mississippi Blues Trail marker at his birthplace, Muddy Waters claimed to have been born in Rolling Fork and his birth year has been variously reported as 1913, 1914, and 1915. https://msbluestrail.org/blues-trail-markers/muddy-waters-birthplace

[xviii] Lomax, Alan. Alan Lomax Collection, Manuscripts, Mississippi, Tennessee and Arkansas, -1942. to 1942, 1941. Manuscript/Mixed Material. https://www.loc.gov/item/afc2004004.ms070208/.

[xx] Lomax, Alan. Alan Lomax Collection, Manuscripts, Mississippi, Tennessee and Arkansas, -1942. to 1942, 1941. Manuscript/Mixed Material. https://www.loc.gov/item/afc2004004.ms070352/.

[xxi] The Complete Plantation Recordings Muddy Waters, 1941- 1942, Chess/ MCA, 1993.

[xxii] “Country Blues” and “Interview #1” from The Complete Plantation Recordings Muddy Waters, 1941- 1942, Chess/ MCA, 1993.

[xxiii] Karl Rohr, “Muddy Waters.”

[xxiv] Michael Hill. “Muddy Waters Hall of Fame Essay.”

[xxv] Robert Gordon, “Can’t Be Satisfied.” American Masters. PBS, May 24, 2006. https://www.pbs.org/wnet/americanmasters/muddy-waters-cant-be-satisfied/730/.

[xxvi] Michael Hill, 1987, “Muddy Waters Hall of Fame Essay.”

[xxvii] David Whiteis, n.d. “Blues Breakthrough at Newport.”

[xxviii] Christine Wilson, “Mississippi Blues,” Mississippi History Now, Mississippi Department of Archives and History, August 2003.  https://www.mshistorynow.mdah.ms.gov/issue/mississippi-blues.

[xxix] “Did Muddy Waters’ First UK Tour Launch The British Blues Boom?” October 16, 2023, https://www.udiscovermusic.com/stories/muddy-waters-first-uk-tour/

[xxx] Britto, David. “Artists that were influence by Muddy Waters: The American blues legend has left his mark on music and movies,” Rolling Stone India, April 4, 2023. https://rollingstoneindia.com/artists-influenced-by-muddy-waters-jimi-hendrix-rolling-stones-eric-clapton-martin-scorsese/.

[xxxi] Michael Hill, “Muddy Waters Hall of Fame Essay.”

[xxxii] “The Blues had a Baby and They Named it Rock ‘N” Roll,” Lyrics.com. https://www.lyrics.com/lyric/1072858/Muddy+Waters/The+Blues+Had+a+Baby+and+They+Named+It+Rock+%26+Roll

[xxxiii] Michael Hill, “Muddy Waters Hall of Fame Essay.”

[xxxiv] Karl Rohr, “Muddy Waters.”

[xxxv] Robert Palmer, “Muddy Waters: 1915- 1983: An obituary of the blues legend, with memories from Eric Clapton, Bonnie Raitt, Keith Richards and more,” Rolling Stone, June 23, 1983.

[xxxvi] Recording Academy Grammy Awards. Lifetime Achievement Awards. https://www.grammy.com/awards/lifetime-achievement-awards

[xxxvii] Recording Academy Grammy Awards.

[xxxviii] “Muddy Waters Birthplace- Rolling Fork” Mississippi Blues Trail marker, Mississippi Department of Archives and History. https://msbluestrail.org/blues-trail-markers/muddy-waters-birthplace

[xxxix] Naman Ramachandran, “Mick Jagger on New Rolling Stones Album, U.S. Politics and Mortality: ‘As You Get Older, a Lot of Your Friends Die,’” Variety, October 20, 2023. https://variety.com/2023/music/global/mick-jagger-rolling-stones-hackney-diamonds-1235762963/